No it wouldn't. Your eyes don't have a frame rate, so you just get motion blur. It needs the interference effect between camera frame rate and the rate at which objects with rotational symmetry overlay themselves to generate the illusion of slowed, stopped or reversed rotation.
I think it would. My reason being the rings of patterns have the black parts spaced differently.
Thinking of car rims its easily visible when they go at certain speeds they appear to be rotating counter clockwise. Some parts would have that effect whilst other parts wouldnt