the-smiling-buddha ask yourself this,if a tree falls in a forest, and nobody's around, does it make a sound?
To answer the question simply define 'sound'.
If by 'sound' you mean an energy wave dissipating through the air, yes a sound is made whether someone is there or not.
If by 'sound' you mean that same energy wave hitting a person's ear drum and being converted to an electrical signal that is detected by the auditory cortex - then there would be no sound.
This question (and its variations) is often set up as some kind of deep-seated profundity, but is in fact a trivial mechanical question that relies on equivocation for it's 'mystery'.
As for the red lights, I am a consequentialist.
My prediction is that as technology becomes increasingly available and people become increasingly accepting of government incursion we will - very likely - have cameras specifically targeting cyclists at lights. Maybe.
To answer the question simply define 'sound'.
If by 'sound' you mean an energy wave dissipating through the air, yes a sound is made whether someone is there or not.
If by 'sound' you mean that same energy wave hitting a person's ear drum and being converted to an electrical signal that is detected by the auditory cortex - then there would be no sound.
This question (and its variations) is often set up as some kind of deep-seated profundity, but is in fact a trivial mechanical question that relies on equivocation for it's 'mystery'.
As for the red lights, I am a consequentialist.
My prediction is that as technology becomes increasingly available and people become increasingly accepting of government incursion we will - very likely - have cameras specifically targeting cyclists at lights. Maybe.