| | #153 |
| | I did this poster. It isn’t blaming cyclists. It’s instructing them to hold back and take care around lorries, especially left-turning lorries, at junctions, as the driver of the lorry literally cannot physically see any of the cyclists in this area. It’s that simple. Here’s a film we shot on the shoot to show that none of the bikes can be seen from the driver’s seat. You may not agree but at the very least it’s got cyclists talking about it. Which is good, no? |
| quote reply |
| | #155 | ||
| | Great. Quote:
Quote:
I agree it's a good poster, and i'm glad it's raising the profile of the issue, showing just how flawed lorries are. Incidentally, it looks like you had the perfect set-up to try my idea. | ||
| quote reply |
| | #156 |
| | Why don't they just build all HGVs (tractors and rigids) like this: ![]() Seems like placing the driver's eyeline level with other road users would not only improve their vision but also cause them to be more cautious in general, as there seems to be a correlation between how high (and, to a lesser extent, how far behind the front bumper) you sit and how much of a twat you are as a driver (see Chelsea Tractors). Something to do with perspective, I imagine. I'd certainly be perpetually worried about running into stuff if I was placed that low and forward with 44 tonnes behind me. I realise that this is a radical transformation of the whole architecture of large vehicles, but it has happened before, when they switched from a "conventional" to a "cab-over" layout. Low-floor buses and large mobile cranes already have this layout (i.e. cab in front of the front axle instead of over it), so it looks feasible. Obviously changing the "Construction and Use" regulations to place an upper limit on driver's eyeline would, as an unintended consequence, outlaw tall bikes, but it's a small price to pay. |
| quote reply |
| | #157 |
| | "None of these cyclists can be seen because the HGV doesn't have decent mirrors, and even if it does, the driver is probably not looking at them anyway. Even if the driver hits you and is found to be not looking at the road, they will get a piddling fine and probably keep their licence" |
| quote reply |
| | #159 |
| | Don't know if it's been posted yet, but here's an article by Charlie on recent initiatives and the LCC's new 'No More Lethal Lorries' campaign: http://www.guardian.co.uk/environmen...cling-campaign ![]() Oliver LCC |
| quote reply |
| | #160 |
| | I saw a non-tfl poster warning against undertaking stuck on the back of a bus yesterday. It was by one of the london groups (sorry can't remember who). I know that these things don't have the biggest budget in the world, and you have to make the best of what you've got, but the poster was quite bizarre - it showed a really clunky photoshop of a smashed bike and a girl crawling out from under the wheels of a HGV, with a twirly italic hard-to-read font spelling out 'don't undertake large vehicles' set at a weird angle (I had to get 2 feet away before I could read what it was even saying!). I know its important to get the message out, but the way it was constructed really struck the wrong cord with me. Last edited by konijn; 6th August 2010 at 08:41. |
| quote reply |
| | #161 | |
| | Quote:
![]() http://davesbikeblog.squarespace.com...the-world.html | |
| quote reply |
| | #162 | |
| | Quote:
http://lcc.org.uk/index.asp?Pageid=2024 ![]() We're not very happy about this at all, see link. | |
| quote reply |
| | #167 |
| | Close up of the fakery. http://image.bayimg.com/capenaacd.jpg |
| quote reply |
| | #168 |
| | That poster is just terrible. By the way, our new HGV campaign has just been launched: http://www.lcc.org.uk/index.asp?PageID=1911 ![]() Oliver LCC |
| quote reply |
| | #169 |
| | Off the top of my head.... IF YOU HAVEN'T MADE EYE CONTACT WITH THE DRIVER THEN ASSUME THAT HE HAS NOT SEEN YOU AND IS ABOUT TO DO THE FUCKING WORST THING POSSIBLE FROM YOUR POINT OF VIEW. IF HE'S DRIVING A LORRY OR A NATIONAL EXPRESS COACH HE PROBABLY DOESN'T GIVE A FUCK WHETHER HE KILLS YOU EITHER SO THE ABOVE COUNTS DOUBLE. UNDERTAKING / FILTERING ON THE INSIDE IS FUCKING STUPID UNLESS YOU ARE 110% SURE THAT YOU WILL BE SIGNIFICANTLY IN FRONT OF THE VEHICLE YOU ARE UNDERTAKING BEFORE THE THING HAS ANY CHANCE WHATSOEVER OF MOVING. AND TRY OVERTAKING, IT'S SAFER. then a series of photos of splattered cyclists underneath lorries turning left. |
| quote reply |
| | #176 |
| | I don't understand why it's not mandatory for hgvs and other large or articulated vehicles to display a standard, prominent warning. ![]() Not that one, but something more obvious, simply "Cyclists. Do not pass this vehicle on the inside" It's not going to cost millions, much like blindspot mirrors, there seems no reason not to do it. |
| quote reply |
| | #179 | |
| | Quote:
I had to warn a woman the other day who kept trying to scoot inside a massive bulk carrier on Finborough rd the other day, the vehicle had no such sign, but might have made her think a bit more if it had. Of course it's not going to stop poor and dangerous driving, but as I said there's no good reason not to make it mandatory. | |
| quote reply |
| | #181 |
| | The 'suicide' one is wrong: it's not suicide if the driver does not look in his mirror or is on the phone or drunk. It puts the blame unquestioningly on the cyclist and that's not acceptable. Cyclists may die because of their ignorance of the dangers of going up the inside of HGVs but ignorance is not an act of volition. |
| quote reply |
| | #184 |
| | And not being a complete fucking shitbrain should be compulsory for all drivers of any vehicle. But is it? No, I saw a woman today, in a van, bombing down a residential street about 40 in a 20 limit, past a school whilst holding her phone in both hands and texting. More people need to loose their licences and right quick. |
| quote reply |
| | #191 | |
| | Quote:
| |
| quote reply |
| | #192 |
| | Suicide sounds about right to me. If anything, I think it is the cyclist 'fault' (if you want to put it that way) for undertaking because the driver can't see you in their mirrors. What do you want the driver to do? Get out and run round the side and check for bicycles before making any turns? I think the responsibility lies with the cyclist to pass on the other side. |
| quote reply |
| | #193 |
| | Not necessarily, here's one scenario: An HGV pulls up to the lights and it goes red after he ('he' for the sake of this example) has crossed the stop line but chooses not to go because there is a back up of traffic at the turn, but is now in the ASL (and legally allowed). An inexperienced cyclist follows a cycle lane up the left to the ASL but stays in the ASL (where the driver can't see him). While coming up the side the HGV driver turns the indicator on to signal a left turn. But the cyclist is infront of the indicators so doesn't see it. Light goes green and cyclist goes starts riding to go straight, not realising he's completely in the driver's blind spot... Point is that cycle lanes misdirect inexperienced cyclists into dangerous situations, because they are painted on the road and they may think that they're somehow 'safe'. |
| quote reply |
| | #194 |
| | answer: better cycle lanes. a physical obstacle between the cycle lane and the traffic lane, coming up to the lights and at the lights. (bollards). a cycle lane that's wide enough for cyclists to bunch up. a green light for cyclists that happens a few seconds before the green for motor traffic (and perhaps goes red when the left for traffic is green). a clear continuation of the cycle lane across the junction (painted on the road) so that the presence of cyclists is clear. |
| quote reply |
| | #195 | |
| | Quote:
Secondly, the power is down to the HGV drivers, they have the ability to prevent the death of a cyclists. | |
| quote reply |
| | #196 |
| | I see what you're saying Econodog, Chameleon and Ed. All i'm saying is that there's only so much a lorry driver can do in that situation. If he can't see you it's because the cyclist has actively ridden into his blind spot. Educating cyclists to this fact and having mandatory standardised blind spot warning signs on the back of lorrys and large vehicles would no doubt help to prevent deaths. It's the cylists that are riding into the danger zone and IMO not the drivers fault when things gets fatal. The cyclist has the ability to not put themselves in that position. |
| quote reply |
| | #198 |
| | thomas, when I talked to a HGV drivers, they often mentioned that it's not the amount of safety equipment that'll help prevent cyclist getting killed, but the driving standard. if driven properly, HGV shouldn't result in the death of cyclist. an example would be Will's post; a good drivers make a huge difference than adding all sort of mirrors and electronic gimbots, if we get driving instructor to take cycle training as compulsory, then it would make a massive difference when the driving instructor teach the trainee on how to work with cyclists on the road beside the usual lesson. |
| quote reply |
| | #200 | |
| | Quote:
you can engineer out conflict, even where there's much less space than this, the same basic structure can be used. but you're right. the skinny little cycle lane up the inside at the junction is much more dangerous than nothing at all. | |
| quote reply |
| Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
| |
LinkBacks (?) LinkBack to this Thread: http://www.lfgss.com/thread46710.html | ||||
| Posted By | For | Type | Date | Hits |
| Work begins on London's first two Cycle Superhighways | Post #0 | Refback | 13th July 2010 09:22 | 80 |
| Crap Cycling & Walking in Waltham Forest: July 2010 | Post #0 | Refback | 12th July 2010 12:10 | 1 |
| Crap Cycling & Walking in Waltham Forest: That new TfL lorry and cyclists poster | This thread | Refback | 12th July 2010 08:21 | 36 |
| Crap Cycling & Walking in Waltham Forest | Post #0 | Refback | 12th July 2010 08:17 | 31 |
| TFL bike lane failure, demonstrated by TFL ad : bicycling | This thread | Refback | 9th July 2010 23:19 | 57 |
| 3 new initiatives that make cycling in London safe – will they work? | This thread | Refback | 9th July 2010 08:16 | 51 |
| Cyclists and lorries: how technology can help | Anna Leach | Environment | guardian.co.uk | This thread | Refback | 7th July 2010 10:28 | 6 |
| London FGSS (lfgss) on Twitter | This thread | Refback | 6th July 2010 19:12 | 41 |
Similar Threads | ||||
| Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
| That was fast TFL | dancing james | General | 31 | 23rd March 2010 21:12 |
| Getting Buzzed by HGV's | commie | General | 35 | 10th March 2010 23:34 |
| Fixie poster | ParryMan | General | 15 | 15th June 2009 21:49 |
| HGV Campaign - See the thread now and HELP! | jbcommuter | General | 3 | 4th October 2008 14:32 |
| New poster looking for help | makecoldplayhistory | Bikes & Bits | 32 | 21st April 2008 12:23 |