Notices

 
LinkBack Thread Tools Search this Thread
Old 9th October 2009   #1
talboy
 
talboy's Avatar
Foot touching front wheel?

Hi guys,

Just a quick one if anyone has any tips... im riding a 700c fixed wheel with 170mm cranks and shim spd pedals and normal 2 bolt cleats...

Iv fiound when turning the wheel when my foot is in the most forward position my foot touches a front wheel by a fair bit, iv found it quite hard to then track stand at lights and a few times its almost knocked me off balance badly...

I was thinking of putting some spd sl pedals and buying some road shoes, will this get rid of the problem? Also thought about getting 165mm cranks but fails to see how 5mm will help!!

Any advice is appreciated...
  quote   reply
Old 9th October 2009   #2
Skullydonor
 
Skully's Avatar
It's only a problem if you let it. You'll get used to overlap. Shorter cranks might make it happen less, i.e. more clearance for more of your pedal arc. When you're trackstanding you ought to be turning your wheel the other way, anyway. When dodging through traffic, you get good at allowing for it, after a while.

Basically, just learn to cope with it. The advantages of having a tight bike are worth it.

my 2p!
  quote   reply
Old 9th October 2009   #3
talboy
 
talboy's Avatar
Ok fair enough, so def not worth getting road shoes and pedals then?
  quote   reply
Old 9th October 2009   #4
Skullydonor
 
Skully's Avatar
I have no idea as I use hipster clips and straps.

Basically, yes it might be worth experimenting with things to reduce it, but if the geometry of your frame means it'll happen a bit whatever you do, and you like the frame otherwise, then learn to steer around it. Its only really an issue when you are going at very low speeds or at a standstill.
  quote   reply
Old 9th October 2009   #5
talboy
 
talboy's Avatar
While iv got you dont want to start a new thread so will just ask here, i bought replacement quill off ebay the other day and it arrived i tried it yesterday and when it tightens up the top bolt seems to be recessed quite a bit... that doesn't seem normal is the quil nackered or do i need to just replace the block at the bottom of the bolt which comes up?

Cheers for your help, i do actually like the frame its not a massive issue and im sure ill find ways around it happeneing!!
  quote   reply
Old 9th October 2009   #6
Skullydonor
 
Skully's Avatar
I don;t get the problem, sorry. The top bolt is 'recessed' into the quill? As in it's too narrow for the quill?
  quote   reply
Old 9th October 2009   #7
talboy
 
talboy's Avatar
no as in when i screew the bolt it just goes about an inch down into the stem and then leaves a hollow bit at the top, whereas the old quil that im using now when the stem is tightened the the bolt doent go down at all it sits at the top of the stem....
  quote   reply
Old 9th October 2009   #8
barber
 
barber's Avatar
When trackstanding, turn the wheel towards your forward foot. This will eliminate the problem.

a change of cleats/pedals 'Shouldn't' make any difference at all, because your foot will be in exactly the same position relative to the pedal axle.
  quote   reply
Old 9th October 2009   #9
Sparky
 
Sparky's Avatar
Go to a framebuilder and ask them to build a bike with the bottom bracket right at the back. This will eliminate the problem with the front wheel, and the rear won't be an issue because on most bikes the rear wheel doesn't turn.
  quote   reply
Old 9th October 2009   #10
talboy
 
talboy's Avatar
My back wheel does turn actually, its like those sidewinder skateboard i have to wriggle my hips to make it go forwards...
  quote   reply
Old 9th October 2009   #11
Tiswasdonor
 
Tiswas's Avatar
Toes. Just how much do you need them?
  quote   reply
Old 9th October 2009   #12
Greasy Slagdonor
 
Greasy Slag's Avatar
My commute was west bound from hampstead to white city so with a high percentage of left hand turns i managed to just remove by right toes. quids in!
  quote   reply
Old 9th October 2009   #13
andypdonor
 
andyp's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tiswas View Post
Toes. Just how much do you need them?
We've got 10 so their must be some redundancy built in, no?
  quote   reply
Old 9th October 2009   #14
Sparky
 
Sparky's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by talboy View Post
My back wheel does turn actually, its like those sidewinder skateboard i have to wriggle my hips to make it go forwards...
Before I adjusted the cones on my hybrid my back wheel turned too, uncontrollably and erratically. Was good fun, actually.
  quote   reply
Old 9th October 2009   #15
Sparky
 
Sparky's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by andyp View Post
We've got 10 so their must be some redundancy built in, no?
I have a friend with 8. She doesn't miss them. Seriously.
  quote   reply
Old 9th October 2009   #16
kerley
 
kerley's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sparky View Post
I have a friend with 8. She doesn't miss them. Seriously.
8 may be okay but none at all would make even standing still difficult. I am leaving mine on and just living with toe overlap.
  quote   reply
Old 9th October 2009   #17
Smallfurry
 
Smallfurry's Avatar
You dont need toes to cycle. toes have mass, and in cycling weight counts. So loose the toes. Dont despair though, as they are rotational mass, you gain twice as much by losing them :)
  quote   reply
Old 9th October 2009   #18
Sparky
 
Sparky's Avatar
Why not just scrap feet altogether and have some SPD cleats surgically grafted to the bottom of your leg bones?

Also, ears, nose and other protrusions can be got rid of, surely. And they call professional athletes committed....
  quote   reply
Old 9th October 2009   #19
Malibudonor
 
Malibu's Avatar
I have MTB shoes now on a road bike and had the same problem. I drilled some new holes in my shoes and moved the clits forward.

Sorted
  quote   reply
Old 9th October 2009   #20
Sparky
 
Sparky's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by Malibu View Post
moved the clits
<Smirk>
  quote   reply
Old 9th October 2009   #21
Smallfurry
 
Smallfurry's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sparky View Post
Why not just scrap feet altogether and have some SPD cleats surgically grafted to the bottom of your leg bones?

Also, ears, nose and other protrusions can be got rid of, surely. And they call professional athletes committed....
My bulbus nose predates the Zipp 'eliptical aero shape' working simularly by helping the air pass over my face with less turbulance. Frankly I've half a mind to sue Zipp
  quote   reply
Old 9th October 2009   #22
|³|MA3K
 
|³|MA3K's Avatar
Just buy a mountain bike.
  quote   reply
Old 9th October 2009   #23
Sparky
 
Sparky's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by Smallfurry View Post
My bulbus nose predates the Zipp 'eliptical aero shape' working simularly by helping the air pass over my face with less turbulance. Frankly I've half a mind to sue Zipp
I actually read about this in an article recently...

Quote:
To simulate the same thing you could try DIY wind-tunnel testing. Get a friend to drive at a consistent 30mph and stick your head out of the window. Use sandpaper to modify the shape of your nose and measure aerodynamics by how hard your head is pushed back. After an hour or two of adjustment, you'll really notice the difference!
  quote   reply
Old 9th October 2009   #24
Dutch Cheesedonor
 
Dutch Cheese's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by talboy View Post
no as in when i screew the bolt it just goes about an inch down into the stem and then leaves a hollow bit at the top, whereas the old quil that im using now when the stem is tightened the the bolt doent go down at all it sits at the top of the stem....
I have a 3TTT quill stem with a recessed hex bolt. It goes in about 1 cm and there must be a plastic plug/cap on top of it. Unfortunately I lost it. Maybe someone has one for me.

Also, it's normal for Shimano stems. Also recessed bolts, a couple of cm. deep. Need good tools (or an extra pipe that goes over the hex key). Also covered by a (screwed in) cap.
Again, I have one, but again, missing cap.
  quote   reply
Old 9th October 2009   #25
Smallfurry
 
Smallfurry's Avatar
I ride a 20" BJ and have size EU 44 feet. I'm sure its there, but I've never noticed toe overlap.
  quote   reply
Old 9th October 2009   #26
talboy
 
talboy's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dutch Cheese View Post
I have a 3TTT quill stem with a recessed hex bolt. It goes in about 1 cm and there must be a plastic plug/cap on top of it. Unfortunately I lost it. Maybe someone has one for me.

Also, it's normal for Shimano stems. Also recessed bolts, a couple of cm. deep. Need good tools (or an extra pipe that goes over the hex key). Also covered by a (screwed in) cap.
Again, I have one, but again, missing cap.
Not sure if its because the the quill has an expander at the bottom or what but its doesn't seem right to me.... It does go quite a bit down the tube, im assuming that there is supposed to be a ridge to stop the bolt going down which may have worn out... got it off ebay so will ask thr guy if he wants it back...

I suppose it prob makes no difference to be honest but just would rather it work properly... also its silver and the bars and other bits are black so looks pretty wank so hoping he takes it back!!
  quote   reply
Old 9th October 2009   #27
dommyracer
 
dommyracer's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by talboy View Post

Iv fiound when turning the wheel when my foot is in the most forward position my foot touches a front wheel by a fair bit, iv found it quite hard to then track stand at lights and a few times its almost knocked me off balance badly...
Unclip FTW.
  quote   reply
Old 9th October 2009   #28
Polky
 
Polky's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sparky View Post
Also, ears, nose and other protrusions can be got rid of, surely.
you should keep the nose because it warms and filters the air before it hits your lungs, but you could definitely make the whole head/face more aero... some sort of plastic surgery to push the nose and mouth forward into a dome shape... Then intergrate the eyes on the top like the windshield of a TGV...
  quote   reply
Old 9th October 2009   #29
Tjuice
I would say get used to it, and as Skully says, it sounds like you have the wrong foot forward (or are turning the bars the wrong way) if it is causing problems with your trackstands. Good for you to learn to trackstand both ways anyhow (if you don't already) :-)

I have massive overlap on my geared road bike, but it never causes me any problems. If I am waiting at the lights, typically the camber of the road means I need to turn my bars to the right, and then I have my right foot forward. Both feet are then a long way away from the wheel!

Moving your cleats further forward than they are designed to go means your foot will be too far back for efficient cycling and the pedal axle will be under your toes rather than under the ball of your foot.
  quote   reply
Old 9th October 2009   #30
Tjuice
Quote:
Originally Posted by talboy View Post
Not sure if its because the the quill has an expander at the bottom or what but its doesn't seem right to me.... It does go quite a bit down the tube, im assuming that there is supposed to be a ridge to stop the bolt going down which may have worn out... got it off ebay so will ask thr guy if he wants it back...
Photo would help
  quote   reply
Old 9th October 2009   #31
dickidonor
 
dicki's Avatar
cut bike in half ( making sure cut is made in front of bottom bracket )
weld in an extra 1.5 inches of reynold 531 into gap
weld shut

problem solved
or buy some new forks wit more rake and trail

here's an way to ensure you get it right ... use the following equations

  quote   reply
Old 9th October 2009   #32
dickidonor
 
dicki's Avatar
where

Offset-- Centerline of top of steering neck to centerline of top of fork tubes.
Rake-- The angle in degrees of the steering neck from the vertical.
Fork Length-- The distance between the top of the fork tubes to the centerline of the axle.
Diameter of the front tire.
Diameter of the rear tire.
Trail: Distance defined by vertical line from axle to ground and intersect of centerline of steering neck and ground.
Raked Triple Trees-- In order to bring trail figures back into line, triple trees with raked steering stems can be used. Expressed in degrees. Usually adjustable in 3, 5, and 7 degrees of rake.
Tire Diameter Formula: If you do not know a certain tire diameter use the following formula:
Diam Inches = Rim Diam Inches + [ (2 x Aspect Ratio x Section Width) / 25.4]
Example: 200/55R18 Tire:
26.7" = 18 + [(2 x 0.55 x 200)/25.4]
and
  quote   reply
Old 9th October 2009   #33
Sparky
 
Sparky's Avatar
If you use a section of goose-neck then you don't have to bother with trig. Plus, it will decrease your turning circle and act as suspension, too.
  quote   reply
Old 9th October 2009   #34
Junkhead
 
Junkhead's Avatar

Job done !
  quote   reply
Old 9th October 2009   #35
Dutch Cheesedonor
 
Dutch Cheese's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by dicki View Post
where

Offset-- Centerline of top of steering neck to centerline of top of fork tubes.
Rake-- The angle in degrees of the steering neck from the vertical.
Fork Length-- The distance between the top of the fork tubes to the centerline of the axle.
Diameter of the front tire.
Diameter of the rear tire.

............. blah ....... blah ........
Got an excel sheet for this.
You want it ?
  quote   reply
Old 10th October 2009   #36
dickidonor
 
dicki's Avatar
i wouldn't know where to start but that would be fun
i have always been interested in the front end handling of bikes as a result of steerer tube angle rake and trail
can you postt it to the interwebz somewhere so i can have a look

and if it could be the Dummies guide to ...... it would be much appreciated

as i recall you used to design bikes with gazelle right ? i guess you must know all about this kind of thing

i like the front end of my gazelles sharp steering but pretty solid and not too tricky when bowling along on the flat
  quote   reply
Old 10th October 2009   #37
Dutch Cheesedonor
 
Dutch Cheese's Avatar
I'll put it somewhere.
By the way, it's from another bike company.
When I was at Gazelle, I didn't even have a typewriter.

(and as we say in NL: cat was still written with "un". Actually, we say KAT was written with a U, but that's not so easy to understand for most of you).

Last edited by Dutch Cheese; 12th October 2009 at 08:12.
  quote   reply
Old 12th October 2009   #38
Smallfurry
 
Smallfurry's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by dicki View Post
i wouldn't know where to start but that would be fun
i have always been interested in the front end handling of bikes as a result of steerer tube angle rake and trail
can you postt it to the interwebz somewhere so i can have a look

and if it could be the Dummies guide to ...... it would be much appreciated

as i recall you used to design bikes with gazelle right ? i guess you must know all about this kind of thing

i like the front end of my gazelles sharp steering but pretty solid and not too tricky when bowling along on the flat
Had a nice calculator by Kogswell.com bookmarked but its coming up as account suspended.
The_Smiling_Buddha found a nice one along with a article by the much loved DW.
http://www.londonfgss.com/post648628-38.html

Last edited by Smallfurry; 12th October 2009 at 06:50.
  quote   reply

Bookmarks Shortcuts
Posts Categories

Tags
foot, front, touching, wheel


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
For Sale: Aende Lo-Pro frame & forks, 650c Zipp front wheel, 650c Dura Ace front wheel rik Classifieds & Shopping 53 11th October 2009 09:48
Trade: Charge dish 700c front for 650c front wheel Freddie22 Classifieds & Shopping 1 4th August 2009 13:09
For Sale: Spinergy Rev-X 700c Front Wheel + Mavic 650 Front Wheel BoBoB Classifieds & Shopping 36 27th June 2009 12:15
A touching and slightly macabre tale VanUden General 26 17th April 2009 11:28
Touching up an Aerospoke slaytanic1 Mechanics & Fixin' 14 8th January 2009 07:17

Creative Commons License All times are GMT. The time now is 09:00.
no new posts