LinkBack Thread Tools Search this Thread
Old 3rd June 2009   #1
koens
 
koens's Avatar

Join Date: Oct 2008
Posts: 691
Friends: 32
Location: surebitch
Phil Wood Stainless Steel Bottom Bracket 110.5mm ISO

5 months use, smooth as butter but apparently too big for my brooklyn so it's up for grabs - SOLD

bought from total cycling, listed on track bottom bracket section http://www.totalcycling.com/index.ph...NLESS_ISO.html

i did a quick measure from outside thread to outside thread with housetape measure, not calipers, seemed around 70mm











install instructions http://www.philwood.com/docs/crankbe...ationguide.pdf

Last edited by koens; 5th June 2009 at 17:38. Reason: my own stupidity
  quote   reply
Old 3rd June 2009   #2
Superprecisedonor
drool
  quote   reply
Old 3rd June 2009   #3
31t®umdonor
 
31t®um's Avatar
standard english cups?
  quote   reply
Old 3rd June 2009   #4
Superprecisedonor
i don't think cups are included.
  quote   reply
Old 3rd June 2009   #5
jonlubidonor
 
jonlubi's Avatar
If that would give me a good chainline using Stronglight track cranks and a goldtec hub I would take it.... transmission database doesn't offer this info tho, anyone know if it would?

Trouble is I can't remember what size my UN54 is. Shit. I think it's 110. You do get 5mm adjustment with the Phil cups tho don't you?
  quote   reply
Old 3rd June 2009   #6
31t®umdonor
 
31t®um's Avatar
your shimano UN51, is JIS not ISO
  quote   reply
Old 3rd June 2009   #7
jonlubidonor
 
jonlubi's Avatar
oops.
  quote   reply
Old 3rd June 2009   #8
koens
 
koens's Avatar
i am really stupid today. if i keep the cups i need the tools. doh!

i don't need the cups then they and the tools are up for grabs too

would really liked to have kept this bb in my bike, anyone know if it would be possible? no idea on the bmw bb shell size...

Last edited by koens; 4th June 2009 at 12:34.
  quote   reply
Old 3rd June 2009   #9
dogsballs
 
dogsballs's Avatar
normal 68mm english. adjustable cups means you have some room for moving side to side.
  quote   reply
Old 3rd June 2009   #10
bombadil
says english bb on the bmw website

edit - too late
  quote   reply
Old 3rd June 2009   #11
n!x
Are they symetrical? I need to fit my Campagnolo pista crankset on this. I think the model for symetrical is BRS10S.
  quote   reply
Old 3rd June 2009   #12
koens
 
koens's Avatar
4 pms straight off the bat
  quote   reply
Old 3rd June 2009   #13
koens
 
koens's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by bombadil View Post
says english bb on the bmw website

edit - too late
yeah i knew it was english bb, which is why i bought it for my bmw, but had never installed one before, figured i just needed to adjust it, but 14 mechanic told me it was the wrong one for my bb?

the length (110mm) is from axle to axle yeah?
  quote   reply
Old 3rd June 2009   #14
dogsballs
 
dogsballs's Avatar
spot on for sug 75, to phil/goldtec rear
  quote   reply
Old 3rd June 2009   #15
koens
 
koens's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by dogsballs View Post
spot on for sug 75, to phil/goldtec rear
who's spot on? me or the mechanic?

i've been riding it fine until recently...
  quote   reply
Old 3rd June 2009   #16
maxcrowe
 
maxcrowe's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by jonlubi View Post
If that would give me a good chainline using Stronglight track cranks and a goldtec hub I would take it.... transmission database doesn't offer this info tho, anyone know if it would?

Trouble is I can't remember what size my UN54 is. Shit. I think it's 110. You do get 5mm adjustment with the Phil cups tho don't you?
sorry to derail but how are these? i'm thinking of getting some just wondering what you think
  quote   reply
Old 3rd June 2009   #17
woolsdonor
 
wools's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by koens View Post
who's spot on? me or the mechanic?

i've been riding it fine until recently...
What happened "recently"?...
  quote   reply
Old 3rd June 2009   #18
koens
 
koens's Avatar
the locktite didn't hold and the bb moved some mm's to the drive side. when previously i could see threads on both sides i could only see it on the drive side now.

so apparently the bb is 73mm and the bmw bb shell is 68.

ok i'm confused, are bb shells a standard width? are bb a standard width? if i know my bb is iso square taper as are my sugino 75s, and my bb shell is british and my cups are british, i would it all have worked together. and it did. but not perfectly. where did i go wrong? maybe i should post this in mechanics...

ps thanks to jakob and andy at 14 for sorting my new wheels, bb and chain!
  quote   reply
Old 4th June 2009   #19
mikeymerk
 
mikeymerk's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by dogsballs View Post
spot on for sug 75, to phil/goldtec rear
but not the frame...
  quote   reply
Old 4th June 2009   #20
dogsballs
 
dogsballs's Avatar
but with adjustable cups you should be able to adjust it?!?!
  quote   reply
Old 4th June 2009   #21
socialamnesiadonor
 
socialamnesia's Avatar
dale - the bb is 2.5 mm too wide for the frame on either side, the spindle length is correct - how does he adjust to account for the lack of thread in contact with the bb shell without severely compromising his chainline?.....

the only possible security he could have is by bunging a couple of bb lockrings from a loose bearing bb on.
  quote   reply
Old 4th June 2009   #22
socialamnesiadonor
 
socialamnesia's Avatar
@koens - am i to assume that by editing me out of your post you dont want to sell to me any more?
  quote   reply
Old 4th June 2009   #23
dogsballs
 
dogsballs's Avatar
ah i get you, fuck up with order of BB, 73mm instead of 68mm. i thought it was a 68 bb in 73 shell.
  quote   reply
Old 4th June 2009   #24
socialamnesiadonor
 
socialamnesia's Avatar
painful on an £80 bb...
  quote   reply
Old 4th June 2009   #25
koens
 
koens's Avatar
did i edit you out of the post? sorry didn't mean to, just wanted to provide the correct information for an objective opinion.

also as i now know i don't need the cups i want to sell as one lot.

the bb was listed on total cycles track bottom bracket section

http://www.totalcycling.com/index.ph...NLESS_ISO.html

i did a quick measure from outside thread to outside thread with housetape measure, not calipers, seemed around 70mm
  quote   reply
Old 4th June 2009   #26
socialamnesiadonor
 
socialamnesia's Avatar
answered that one on your other thread about this http://www.londonfgss.com/thread23119.html -

probably worth attempting a complaint.
  quote   reply
Old 4th June 2009   #27
dogsballs
 
dogsballs's Avatar
this doesn't make sense, that should be for a 68mm shell according to site. could be total cycling fuck up.

edit, as SA says in other thread

you could sell the BB to MTBer's, then buy a 68mm one
  quote   reply
Old 4th June 2009   #28
woolsdonor
 
wools's Avatar
Koens, mate, I'm out. Sorry. I asked our resident mechanic guru (dogsballs) about the shell and BB size issue and he says I'd be in the same boat as you with the BB shell on my Bob Jackson. Sorry dude.
  quote   reply
Old 4th June 2009   #29
koens
 
koens's Avatar
yeah no worries, that's whay i wanted to update the details, but what i'm gonna do is get some digi calipers and take a pic to put an end to the mystery...
  quote   reply
Old 4th June 2009   #30
socialamnesiadonor
 
socialamnesia's Avatar
after two mechanics opinion and your own experience of it being too big you're still going to measure it ......?

i'll bet you a bb it's a 73mm :P
  quote   reply
Old 4th June 2009   #31
woolsdonor
 
wools's Avatar
If it ends up being a 68mm one then I'll happily take it. But then I guess it'd be working on your Brooklyn and you'd want to keep it. Anyway, I'll be keeping an eye on this here thread. I wanna know the outcome!
  quote   reply
Old 4th June 2009   #32
koens
 
koens's Avatar
ha! they all say 68/73 mm! http://philwood.com/store/page30.html

i guess it's the 5mm of adjustment it allows, so i guess everyone is right!
  quote   reply
Old 4th June 2009   #33
socialamnesiadonor
 
socialamnesia's Avatar
hmmm, so whats the pecking order for buying this then?
  quote   reply
Old 4th June 2009   #34
kx.001
I'm so confused

Although thats not difficult
  quote   reply
Old 4th June 2009   #35
socialamnesiadonor
 
socialamnesia's Avatar
ha! ...........dibs are a minefield
  quote   reply
Old 4th June 2009   #36
koens
 
koens's Avatar
ok so whoever wants the lot for £70 can have it, in this order;

socialamnesia
wools
31trum
lalanternerouge
kx.001
  quote   reply
Old 4th June 2009   #37
dogsballs
 
dogsballs's Avatar
if it is 73, you just have to centre it in the BB, ie 2.5mm show each side and should be fine, spindle is the same. unless cups hit crank arms.
  quote   reply
Old 4th June 2009   #38
socialamnesiadonor
 
socialamnesia's Avatar
gwan then.... - any one need a set of bb tools for a phil?
  quote   reply
Old 4th June 2009   #39
woolsdonor
 
wools's Avatar
So what's going on with this? Is it 68mm or 73mm? Or both? Calling all peeps with Phil Wood BBs!

Should this turn out to be compatible with my frame is this mine?
  quote   reply
Old 4th June 2009   #40
woolsdonor
 
wools's Avatar
@SA - How much would you sell them for? Dibs!
  quote   reply
Old 4th June 2009   #41
koens
 
koens's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by socialamnesia View Post
gwan then.... - any one need a set of bb tools for a phil?
wools and lpg both want tools i think
  quote   reply
Old 4th June 2009   #42
lpg
i only need one tool. wools - split?
  quote   reply
Old 4th June 2009   #43
socialamnesiadonor
 
socialamnesia's Avatar
lpg - wools is out - you want to make an offer on tools i have yet to posess...
  quote   reply
Old 5th June 2009   #44
koens
 
koens's Avatar
so sa you buying them or is wools?
  quote   reply
Old 5th June 2009   #45
koens
 
koens's Avatar
SOLD to wools... sorry sa, hadn't heard from you since yesterday and thougth you'd lost interest anyways...
  quote   reply


Tags
1105mm, bottom, bracket, phil, stainless, steel, wood


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Installing a Phil Wood bottom bracket tick.tick.tick Mechanics & Fixin' 18 3 Weeks Ago 06:55
Wanted: Campagnolo 110.5mm bottom bracket spindle... Soweto888 Classifieds & Shopping 2 19th April 2009 19:33
Wanted: 110 Phil Wood axle Clever Pun Classifieds & Shopping 2 16th April 2009 14:45
Wanted: 110-111mm Bottom Bracket. Elguapo Classifieds & Shopping 2 13th November 2008 12:26
103mm ISO Bottom Bracket required help... jodie_harsh Bikes & Bits 9 15th May 2008 16:29

All times are GMT. The time now is 06:11.
Creative Commons License, BY-SA v2.0
no new posts