perhaps I should just gift LFGSS in it's entirety to LFGSS CIC
This (apart from the gift element) was a thought which occurred to me last time I looked at this thread.
since I was offered money for LFGSS
What order of magnitude? The comedy online site valuation tools (and I use the term advisedly) give valuations of anywhere from $10 to £130k. I ask because the thought which occurred to me was to have the CIC/Cycling Club acquire lfgss.com by a buy-out funded by a one-off subscription from cycling club members. In the olden days, clubs would sometimes have a subscription to purchase a memorial trophy, for example, and raise total sums of the order of a month's salary of the average member, but I wasn't sure whether the amount which could be easily raised this way would be comically short of a commercial valuation.
In the light of your considering gifting it to the CIC, the commercial value is less relevant, but my understanding is that lfgss.com has had it's historic deficits funded by you personally, so some contribution towards making up those losses would seem to be the least we could do in respect of any transfer of ownership.